(Beth Wilmurt and Joy Carlin in classic sitcom staging in Marin Theatre Company's production. Photo by Kevin Berne.)
At times The Beauty Queen of Leenane,
now at Marin Theatre Company, felt so much like a domestic sitcom that I
half-expected to see three tv cameras between the performers and the (studio)
audience. Rural Irish mother and daughter Mag (Joy Carlin) and Maureen (Beth
Wilmurt) would fit right in in George Costanza's family if they replaced their
Gaelic brogue for a New York one. Nina Ball's set might isolate them from the
rest of the world — their wall-less kitchen is surrounded by swaths of fabric that
suggest a fog; they are floating in space, but the mist is closing in — but
inside the setup is as familiar as that of the pre-prime time re-run lineup. One family
member sits in her chair, the other at the table, as they trade barbs about how
they wish one another were dead. Somewhere, Jason Alexander is yelling
constipatedly.
The plot of Martin McDonagh’s comic drama seems
television-simple as well. Maureen has been stuck taking care of her weaselly
yet doltish mother for years, but as the play begins, Pato (Rod Gnapp), an old
crush, returns to County Connemara, potentially giving her a ticket out.
Melodramatic hairpin turns follow (the plot hinges on storytelling devices from
another era: letters and messengers!), revealing Maureen as much more similar
to her mother than the daughter would care to admit.
So far, this doesn’t resemble the kind of work I’ve
lately seen from director Mark Jackson. Typically, his plays are anything but
conventional, particularly in their staging; his blocking is kinetic, fluid,
and evocative. Static movement suits this play’s setting and themes, of course.
But in both style and content, this production struck me as much more generic,
something any director could have done, rather than having the distinct Jackson
imprint I usually so enjoy.
But I am leaving out the play’s saving grace. Maureen
is more than a restless, put-upon forty-year-old. She is also deeply troubled,
so much so that her vision of the world is skewed. This first manifests itself
subtly, as when she interprets an offhand remark from Pato as a scathing
criticism of her looks. But it slowly becomes apparent that Maureen’s acerbic
jokes aren’t just jokes; something sinister infects her. McDonagh shows this
side of her in a classically realistic manner: the delayed revelation of a dark
family secret. But afterward, he does not make her the object of our pity or
scorn. Rather, we see the world through her eyes, only we don’t know it. The
quasi-realistic, quasi-melodramatic world that unfolds is her vision projected
onto the stage. And when we find out that what we see is a lie, her lie, the
one she tells herself, and that we’ve been believing it, too — it’s one of the
most compelling stagings I’ve ever seen of the idea that for the troubled, what
they see isn’t “crazy”; for them it’s real and normal – plain as day,
observable by the senses. It makes me wonder how much of my reality is
verifiable by outside sources and how much is something I’ve talked myself
into.
(Joy Carlin's elastic face. Photo by Kevin Berne.)
Jackson’s cast is uniformly excellent, particularly
Carlin, who can do broad physical comedy with her face and voice alone. She
seems to have the ability to bisect her face vertically, so that each half is
making its own expression; it’s often a lopsided smile: one side is a slack-jawed,
“Who, me?” half-grin; the other is alert and sharp, scheming to keep Maureen in
her place.
With their talents, Beauty Queen always entertains, but its true payoff comes only
toward the end. I only wish the direction had helped bring the script out of
sitcomland a little earlier.
The
Beauty Queen of Leenane continues through June 16; info here.